A Mind to Murder (Inspector Adam Dalgliesh Mystery)

Product Information

The legal position remains: there is no case to answer (nor could a jury properly convict) for the offences of murder or manslaughter where the prosecution cannot prove who killed the victim. In a case where there is more than one such suspect and the section 5 offence is charged, it may in addition be appropriate to charge the suspects with murder or manslaughter. If a defendant pleads not guilty to murder but guilty to manslaughter without that appearing as a count on the indictment, that plea is a nullity if the prosecution does not accept it. The defendant cannot be sentenced for it in the event of acquittal on the count of murder. It should therefore, as suggested above, be put to the defendant on a two-count indictment; if the defendant pleads guilty to the second count of manslaughter, it is the first count on which the defendant can then be tried by a jury: Hazeltine [1967] 2 QB 857; Yeardley [2000] 2 WLR 366.

The suspect was not wholly motivated by compassion; for example, the suspect was motivated by the prospect that they or a person closely connected to them stood to gain in some way from the death of the victim; sets out the importance of considering murder or manslaughter in cases of suicide, in particular in a domestic abuse context Okay, the story of a woman who works in a medical facility (psychiatric, circa 1962 where lysergic acid (LSD) treatments are de rigueur) is brutally murdered - with a chisel, no less! - in the records archive on the basement floor. Yep, it starts with that, isn't too-graphically presented and we're left with the handsome and urbane Adam Dalgliesh, and his assistant Martin, to sort it all out.On the whole of the evidence, including that of both defendants, the prosecution reflected whether there was a case for either defendant to answer. Once it concluded that the case should be withdrawn against one or other defendant, it was obliged to say so. This was not an abuse of process. Rather it was the process working as it should, with the prosecution acting responsibly in its venerable and still contemporaneously valid role as a minister of justice." There is no definition of 'mercy killing' in statute or common law. An offender who takes the life or attempts to take the life of a victim may act on the wishes of the victim and may act out of mercy, but this does not provide a defence in law. The victim had reached a voluntary, clear, settled and informed decision that they wished for their life to end.

James, P. D. (20 November 2008). A Certain Justice. Faber & Faber. ISBN 9780571248704 . Retrieved 25 June 2023– via Google Books. Often in the novel, Dalgliesh puts himself into the mind of other characters, some of whom are simply innocents caught up in the search for the killer, and some of whom are under suspicion, such as Frederica Saxon.Death of an Expert Witness (1983): Dalgliesh, assisted by Massingham (played by John Vine), leads the hunt for an elusive strangler in The Fens. If the prosecution submits that the judge should accept the verdict of manslaughter, then it will be accepting that it will not be proceeding to a retrial on the charge of murder. Young, Laurel A. (9 June 2017). P.D. James: A Companion to the Mystery Fiction. ISBN 9781476628905.

Deborah Riscoe is one of Dalgliesh's romantic interests; they first meet when a murder shakes Riscoe's home in Cover Her Face; their relationship develops over the course of A Mind to Murder. However, because of Dalgliesh's reluctance to commit, Riscoe ends their relationship via a letter at the conclusion of Unnatural Causes, accepting a transfer to the United States of America. The writing I thought was good, but honestly the flow was off. I think the book needed to be edited a bit tighter since we tended to wander around in some of the characters story-lines way too long. For example, the whole thing with Frederica was one of those story-lines.Dalgliesh lives in an existential funk. Of course, we all do, but many of us are able to keep the confusion, dread and sorrow of life at bay. Not him, not so much. Dalgliesh is human. The subject of all literature is the human being. In A Mind to Murder, James is already grappling with the questions at the heart of human existence. Bereaved Families - Guidance on CPS service to bereaved families in homicide cases and the National Standards of Support after acquittal. The suspect reported the death to the police and fully assisted them in their enquiries into the circumstances and their part in it.

The following public interest factors are not exhaustive. Prosecutors should evaluate the factors below in accordance with the guidance in the Code for Crown Prosecutors. Prosecutors will offer to meet bereaved relatives and partners in homicide cases at important stages of the criminal justice process to explain the anticipated progress of the case, what is expected to happen at each court hearing and the possible sentences available for the offences charged. For further details see the CPS Service to Bereaved Families in Homicide Cases. Provision of information to third parties The trial judge should consider the three components sequentially. If sufficient evidence is adduced to raise this defence, on which in the opinion of the trial judge a jury, properly directed, could reasonably apply, then the prosecution must disprove loss of control beyond reasonable doubt. For the relevant law and jury directions for loss of control, see the Judicial College's Crown Court Compendium, Part I, at 19-3.

Further reading

An objective test (the third component): A person of D's sex and age, with a normal degree of tolerance and self-restraint and in the circumstances of D, might have reacted in the same or in a similar way to D. I didn't like this one as well as the first in the series. I did like Dalgliesh himself, and I learning a few more facts about his life, and the way he thinks. I also liked solid, reliable Inspector Martin. But the supporting cast of characters was less interesting. I was less interested in the the staff of a psychiatric clinic than a small group of family and friends in a country village. In fact, I was only mildly interested in a couple of the doctors (Dr. Steiner and Dr. Saxon), but they aren't really major characters. Not a bad read, and I would recommend it to people who read British mysteries or who have decided they want to read this series. The victim did not have the capacity (as defined by the Mental Capacity Act 2005) to reach an informed decision to request another to end their life;